Simien & Simien, LLC


(800) 374-8422

Click To Call
Update: Simien & Simien is open and we are here to help you as we know your needs do not stop. The firm is currently open and operating. In light of current public health concerns, please know that we are following all health guidelines to protect both our team and our clients. We are offering virtual meetings by request.

Industry insiders cite erosion in America’s crash-test program

When a commentator in a recent media piece states that consumers in Louisiana and nationally “can’t separate the lemons from the peaches,” he isn’t spotlighting a supermarket glitch in the produce section.

Rather, what Consumer Federation of American Executive Director Jack Gillis underscores via that comment is a growing auto safety problem linked with a once vaunted crash-test program that is now reportedly a shell of its former self.

Multiple auto industry insiders and safety experts echo Gillis’ complaint concerning America’s U.S. New Car Assessment Program (NCAP). That initiative was literally rolled out back in 1979 with the introduction of a star-linked rating system that now influences safety evaluations of vehicles globally.

The problem with NCAP, say legions of critics currently, is that it simply hasn’t kept up with the times.

“It’s easily manipulated by the automakers,” stated ex-NHTSA head Joan Claybrook at a recent press conference focused on NCAP history. Claybrook criticizes the crash program inaugurated four decades ago during her tenure as safety chief for failing to keep pace with vehicle updates and related technology enhancements.

As noted, other prominent authorities in the safety realm echo a similar refrain.

David Ward’s view must certainly command respect. Ward is president of Global NCAP, a huge international program based on original NCAP crash-test principles. His organization is now widely viewed as having far surpassed the U.S. program in contemporary relevance.

Ward stresses that the founding NCAP was once “the biggest gift to the world in terms of auto safety,” but now lags other testing bodies outside the U.S.

NCAP critics stress a compelling need for a materially updated vehicle safety testing regime in the United States to supplant the easily manipulated star rating system.

The NHTSA states that it is presently working on program improvements. An agency principal says that NCAP change will be accelerated “to keep pace with advancements in safety technology.”

Louisiana motorists and other drivers nationally will obviously benefit from that.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
FindLaw Network

Free Case Evaluation

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

If you are looking for a law firm that has knowledge and experience, you will find it with Simien & Simien, LLC.

Free Case Evaluation


Baton Rouge
7908 Wrenwood Blvd
Baton Rouge, LA 70809

Toll Free: 800-374-8422
Phone: 225-224-2222
Fax: 225-932-9286
Map & Directions

Lake Charles
Capital One Tower
Suite 1270
One Lakeshore Dr.
Lake Charles, LA 70629

Toll Free: 800-374-8422
Phone: 337-436-2121
Map & Directions

New Iberia
424 West Main St
New Iberia, LA 70560

Toll Free: 800-374-8422
Phone: 337-551-4242
Map & Directions

Houston Office
3730 Kirby Drive
Suite 1200
Houston, TX 77098

Toll Free: 800-374-8422
Map & Directions

New Orleans Office
1615 Poydras Street
Suite 900
New Orleans, LA 70112

Toll Free: 800-374-8422
Map & Directions

Nationwide (800) 374-8422